Judge Ruled Google Should Open Play Store To Other Apps

The court has spoken. Google has no choice, but to open up the Play Store.

This was announced last 7 October by US District Judge James Donato when he issued a permanent injunction forcing the company to open its storefront to competitors for three years and make Android apps available in other stores. The ruling was a result of Google’s four-year antitrust battle with Epic Games. Google said it will appeal the injunction, highlighting its competition with Apple and potential security concerns.

As part of the ruling, Google must allow third-party app stores access to the Google Play library. In addition, CNBC reports that the company has to make those alternate app stores available for download in the Play Store. The ruling also states that Google can’t make deals (using fees or revenue sharing) to launch apps exclusively on Google Play or preinstall its store on new hardware.

Billing changes will also emerge from the injunction. Google can’t require developers to use its own billing system. Nor can it stop devs from notifying users about less expensive payment options.

CNBC reports that a three-person committee will monitor Google’s compliance and technical issues stemming from the ruling. Google and Epic will form the committee.

When asked for comment by Engadget, a Google spokesperson pointed to a blog post explaining why it will appeal. Google VP of Regulatory Affairs Lee-Anne Mulholland wrote that the company’s competition with Apple helps to negate antitrust concerns.

"The decision fails to take into account that Android is an open platform and developers have always had many options in how to distribute their apps," Mulholland wrote. "In fact, most Android devices come preloaded with two or more app stores right out of the box."

"For example, Epic Games has made its popular Fortnite app available to Android users through the Samsung Galaxy Store, sideloading, and the Epic Games Store — all while Fortnite was not distributed through Google Play," Google’s Regulatory Affairs VP wrote. “These are options that developers have never been able to offer to their American users on iPhones."

In December, a jury found Google’s Play Store to violate US antitrust laws. The unanimous verdict stated that the company held an illegal monopoly on app distribution and in-app billing for Android devices. It also ruled that its deals with other gaming companies and device manufacturers were anti-competitive.